Above: Peter Wight and Lesley Manville, Another Year
It is perhaps no accident that two films which depict the abuse of Strong Drink by certain of its characters, as well as the significant consequences of said abuse, should be opening in the interim between the Christmas and New Year's holidays, but I suspect that the timing of the rollouts of Mike Leigh's Another Year and Derek Cianfrance's Blue Valentine have more to do with awards-season strategizing than being of public/spiritual service, or any such thing. I like Another Year very very much, and Blue Valentine somewhat; I review them for MSN Movies here and here.
While none of the "A" words are ever uttered in either picture, both of these films share alcoholism as a theme. Indeed, the story arc of the "present day" portion of Blue Valentine is practically, well, schematic in this respect. "We'll get drunk, make love," Ryan Gosling's character Dean says to his wife Cindy (Michelle Williams), offering her a "day off" at a kind of rendezvous motel to which he has a gift certificate. Trying to distract the both of them from the problems of the day, he thinks he's offering an enticement. And of course the problems are not only not solved, they're not even forgotten during their jaunt; and they in fact get worse, as Dean drinks more and more. In Another Year some of the depictions of behavior are so thoroughly accurate they may feel like a slap in the face, and/or induce a shudder; I can tell you that even from the vantage point of not having picked up a drink for a good length of time, the sight of Peter Wight's Ken waddling down the aisle of a moving train, balancing two cans of lager as he returns from the bar car to his seat, made me squirm in my own movie theater chair. The way Lesley Manville's Mary only ever consumes white wine, and kinda makes a point of it, is scarily telling also. And it's also bite-your-lip time when Ken expresses interest in Mary, and Mary responds with ew-gross dismissiveness. It's a kind of bitter, condensed master class in intra-drunk heterosexual relations, if you will. These notes are acute enough to mislead some reviewers into believing that Leigh's passing judgment on his characters; I don't think he is. And I believe that, if films are in some respects Rorschach tests, a preoccupation with what Leigh supposedly "thinks" about his characters says a fair bit more about the person voicing that preoccupation than it does about the film. This may be particularly so in the case of this film.
As for the beleaguered (as I'm sure she'd be the first to tell you) Karina Longworth and her own review of Another Year for the Village Voice (no link, you can Google it, but trust me...), well, it pretty much got what was coming to in in the comments thread in the post below this one, but the thing I was gonna ask was: What is it with these Twitterific Kidcritz™ going on as if having sat through The Human Centipede is some kind of accomplishment or testament to their endurance or whatever? Really? That all you got? For that reason, Tim Lucas' sort-of admiring but across-the-board blasé writeup of said film in the new (#160) issue of Video Watchdog is kind of a tonic. Highly recommended, as all issues of Video Watchdog are...
Recent Comments