« Relaxin' with Howard Hawks: "El Dorado," 1966/67 | Main | Rescuing "Mavericks," or, "Positif" Vibrations »

January 31, 2009

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

bill

I'd just like to point out that you guys are arguing about which one of you is older. Carry on.

Glenn Kenny

I should try and get Elliott Carter to come out and comment here. He's literally 100, so he'd shut everybody up.

But seriously...this weighs upon me. The problem with getting one's claws out is that sometimes you're cheered on by confreres, vociferously or not, and then some other confreres might reasonably point out that speaking snark to the relatively powerless might not be the best use of one's time, and then everybody's yelling at each other, and it gets like the end of "America Drinks and Goes Home" on the Mothers' "Absolutely Free." And I have pretty much zero leg to stand on in the "calm down, people" department.

Still. Let's. Calm down I mean. I think we all want the same thing, maybe just disagree on tactics. Perhaps those of the original post were overblown, like using a howitzer on a butterfly. Okay, not a butterfly.

Finally, I should point out that I sat through "Nights and Weekends" for a second time this afternoon, so you should all appreciate this special effort at niceness. But something IS brewing...

Charles de Lint

Why in God's great green Earth would you sit through a Joe Swanberg movie twice? I'll tell you what, Glenn, the next time you get the urge to watch one of his films, let me know and I'll send you a Polaroid I took of my junk along with a CD-R I made of a conversation I had with my phlegmatic 15 year old nephew about how he was doing in school.

Glenn Kenny

I hear ya, Charles. As you may have inferred, I didn't do it for entertainment/enjoyment/art value, or for that matter for my health. It's for a piece, one which may elicit strong reactions, that I hope to get up here by Friday or before.

Charles de Lint

Yes. Sounds awesome. I love your writing, Glenn. The stuff for The Auteur Theory website is good, good stuff. Cheers.

Matt

Yes, but what was *driving* the drive that drove her?

MovieMan0283

That's bad writing, to be sure, but does it make her a bad writer? I've written some atrocious prose before, rife with spelling and grammatical errors, only noticing my mistakes when I showed it to someone who doesn't usually read blogs. (We won't even get into my extemporaneous comments here.) Am I a bad writer? I hope not. Or rather, I hope to be judged - at least aesthetically and intellectually - by my best work, not my worst. Also, I have to concur with Tully on another count - you are bigger fish than this young woman, Glenn, so your criticism comes off as cringingly (real word? bad writing?) condescending.

On the other hand, were it not for the snark, would we get such compulsively readable comments sections as the preceeding? Culminating, no less, with this priceless gem from bill:

"I'd just like to point out that you guys are arguing about which one of you is older. Carry on."

Thanks, all.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Tip Jar

Tip Jar
Blog powered by Typepad

Categories